How to Create A Social Media “Expert”
There has been a lot of talk in the past couple of week about the elusive social media expert. It started with Gary Vaynerchuk who called 99.5% of social media experts clowns. Then there was Peter Shankman who wrote an impassioned piece on why he would never, ever, hire a social media expert. While I agree with Peter on some parts (e.g. that social media needs to be integrated into every facet of marketing and cannot be silo’d) I respectfully disagree with a lot of what he wrote. I not only think, I know, that there are SM professionals who do a hell of a lot more than, “build you a fan page, and when all that work doesn’t convert into new sales, say, ‘Well, we’ll just post more.”’ To me, saying there is no use for someone who specializes in a rapidly changing industry makes very little sense.
After Shankman’s post garnered a ton of attention, Stanford from Social Media Today wrote a great post on how to spot a social media expert. His description of a true expert was dead-on, especially the part about the need to be a social scientist – someone who is a student of human nature and is fascinated by seeing what makes people tick. Stanford argues, and I agree, that while such a social media expert is hard to find, a truly good SM professional can be an asset to a company.
So the question remains, if your company is looking to step up its social media game should you look to hire a social media expert? My answer may surprise you, but I am going to say no.
The truth is, you’ll have much better luck if you “grow” your own social media expert.
Social media is still new, so if your employees haven’t reached SM superdome just yet, don’t think that means they never will. An expert can be created if given the right tools and direction. And the good news is – you don’t have to be the one to teach them. You can work with an agency to teach your future expert the lay of the land and to provide continued strategy and analysis. You can empower your expert to identify key blogs and influencers to read and learn from on a daily basis. You can send your expert to conferences, to hear from the best of the best, talk to like-minded people and become inspired by new ideas. And you’ll be doing all this with someone who already knows the ins and outs of your business. Someone who will innately understand how social media ties into customer service or marketing or sales, because that used to be their primary job role. In short, someone who gets it.
So if you are an in-house marketing manager or an agency leader, here are my tips on how to grow your very own social media expert.
Step One: Start with the right person. May seem like a duh, but it is amazing how many people miss this step. Your future expert should be excited to learn about social media. He/she should be smart, a darn good writer and ready to put in the work. This expert should share your vision of reaching social media star status and understand that it may take more than average effort to get there. If you are starting with someone who sees this as an unwelcome addition to their to- do list, they aren’t likely to become a star.
Step Two: Make sure that person reads – a lot. There is no shortage of blogs about social media, marketing, digital strategy, case studies etc. Part of your expert’s job description should be to read daily about what is going on. This will keep he/she up to date on the latest SM technology and trends as well as inspire them with new ideas. A few good ones to start with are Mashable (the SM and business section), Social Media Examiner (has a lot of great case studies) and Jay Baer’s Convince and Convert.
Step Three: Look for outside resources. The web is a great source of knowledge, but nothing beats talking to real people and asking questions. Agencies are an easy way to go for help with this. If you get a good one, they can help train your social media expert on best practices and stay on to assist with strategy. If you don’t want to go the agency route – look for conferences, meet ups, classes, consultants etc. to help your expert learn.
Step Four: Encourage them to watch and emulate. Your expert doesn’t have to come up with entirely new ideas or figure out everything on their own. Have he/she look at what other companies in other industries, or what national brands have done, and see how it could be applied it to your company. Task them with looking at both the big picture ideas and the small tactics. The brands and people that are successful can teach your expert a ton.
Step Five: Let them test. Guess what, sometimes your social media expert is going to get it wrong. Not all ideas are awesome. But testing is key in social media and even if an idea fails overall, there may be elements of it that work. Make sure to give your star the ability to try things, even when he/she isn’t sure it will work. Sometimes those risks will really pay off.
Step 6: Ask them to analyze. As they test and learn, make sure you are tasking them with not only reporting back what worked but why it worked. This will require them to think, a skill they should master if they want to reach expert level.
Step 7: Share and teach. Nothing empowers an expert more than giving them the opportunity to teach others in your company. This is key to ensuring that social media isn’t operating on its own and that the rest of the team understands what your expert is doing and how their efforts can be integrated. It is also a great way to grow your experts knowledge and confidence. Social media is intimidating for many because there is no real “right” answer. But a good social media expert must be confident that whatever direction he/she suggests, is one that they can make work.
So there you have it – my seven steps for growing your very own social media expert. Perhaps as more companies adopt this strategy, we’ll see less articles that claim social media experts are a myth.











Get the employees blogging – Everyone is an expert at something at your company, although not everyone may have a writing background. Encourage the 





